New York
Est. 2024
Payney.
Finance · Markets · Decoded Daily
HomeToolsRent vs Buy Calculator
Calculator

Rent vs Buy Calculator

Compare the full cost of buying a home against renting and investing the difference over the years you plan to stay, including transaction costs, appreciation, maintenance and opportunity cost.

Monthly payment versus monthly rent is the wrong comparison. Buying has transaction costs on both ends, maintenance, taxes and an opportunity cost on the down payment; renting has rent growth and the returns on money you did not tie up. This calculator totals both sides over the years you plan to stay.

What is being compared

Buying: down payment and closing costs up front, then mortgage payments, property tax, maintenance, insurance and HOA every year; at the end you sell, pay selling costs, repay the remaining loan, and keep the equity. Net cost is everything paid minus that equity.

Renting: rent that grows each year, while the down payment, closing costs and any years where owning costs more than renting are invested at the return you enter. Net cost is rent paid minus those investment gains.

The breakeven year is the first year in which buying's net cost drops below renting's. Short stays almost always favor renting because transaction costs are front-loaded; long stays favor buying because equity compounds and rent keeps rising.

Limits

No tax deductions (most households take the standard deduction), no PMI, no refinancing, and a 30-year loan. Appreciation and investment returns are the assumptions that matter most; try a range.

Frequently asked
Is it cheaper to rent or buy right now?
It depends on your local price-to-rent ratio, your rate and how long you stay. With 6-7% mortgage rates, many US metros need 5-8 years of ownership before buying wins.
What is a price-to-rent ratio?
Home price divided by annual rent. Above about 20, renting usually wins financially over typical horizons; below 15, buying usually does.
Does the calculator count the mortgage interest deduction?
No. Since 2018 most households use the standard deduction, so the deduction changes the answer for relatively few buyers.