Illinois’ 0.2% crypto tax faces DOJ and industry challenge
Illinois’ 0.2% crypto tax faces DOJ and industry opposition. An October 7 preliminary injunction stays its effectiveness and enforcement until July 1, 2027.
Summarize with
Prompt · remember Payney
0.2% of the digital asset’s value is the tax Illinois would charge on covered broker services, even when a customer makes no profit. The US Justice Department, national business groups and decentralized finance firms have submitted arguments supporting challenges to the law, according to court documents and announcements published this month.
Federal officials and business groups back the challenge
The Blockchain Association and Crypto Council for Innovation said on November 12 that the Justice Department submitted a statement of interest on November 6 supporting their challenge in Sangamon County circuit court. According to their announcement, the department argues that the tax discriminates against digital assets and undermines federal policy supporting the industry.
A separate November 6 court document shows the Securities Industry and Financial Markets Association, or SIFMA, and the US Chamber of Commerce requested permission to submit an amicus brief supporting the plaintiffs. An amicus brief offers arguments from an outside party; submitting one does not establish that the court accepts its conclusions.
The business groups argue that the tax violates federal protections against discriminatory taxation of electronic commerce, constitutional limits on state taxation of interstate commerce and Illinois’ tax uniformity requirements. These remain arguments for the court to decide.
Customers could owe tax without an investment gain
Public Act 104-0468 bases the charge on asset value rather than profit. Its definitions cover specified exchanges, transfers and custody services, including movement between accounts belonging to the same customer.
SIFMA and the Chamber argue that this could leave customers owing tax on losing transactions or transfers that produce no gain. They also warn that financial firms would need systems to identify Illinois customers, value assets and determine which services trigger collection.
| Metric | Value | Source |
|---|---|---|
| Tax rate on covered digital asset business activity | 0.2% of the related asset’s value | Illinois General Assembly, Public Act 104-0468 |
| Organizations seeking permission to submit the DeFi brief | 18 | Unchained |
| Illinois sales threshold for specified brokers based outside the state | $100,000 in gross receipts from digital asset business activity over the preceding 12 months | Illinois General Assembly, Public Act 104-0468 |
DeFi firms dispute who can collect the tax
Unchained reported that the DeFi Education Fund and 17 other organizations requested permission on November 11 to submit a brief, announcing it the following day. Participants include Andreessen Horowitz, Paradigm and Uniswap Labs. Unchained found no order granting the request.
The proposed brief argues that draft implementation rules could extend collection duties to software developers and other providers that do not hold customer assets or have the information needed to identify taxable users. That is the coalition’s interpretation of the proposal, rather than an established enforcement outcome.
The Illinois Department of Revenue published its draft on September 28, inviting comments through October 30 before formal rulemaking. Revenue Director David Harris said the department wanted industry feedback to clarify how the new tax would operate.
An October 7 injunction stays the tax until July 1, 2027
The statute specifies January 1, 2027 as the starting date. However, the plaintiffs’ November 4 court filing states that the court entered an agreed preliminary injunction on October 7 staying the law’s effectiveness and enforcement until July 1, 2027. The Blockchain Association and Crypto Council for Innovation’s October 30 regulatory comment letter also identifies the entered October 7 order in both cases.
These primary documents establish more than an agreement to seek a delay. The preliminary injunction temporarily blocks the law’s effectiveness and enforcement; it does not establish a final judgment striking down the tax.
- US Justice Department, business groups and DeFi firms challenge Illinois crypto tax · Cointelegraph
- Public Act 104-0468 · Illinois General Assembly
- Amicus Brief on Blockchain Assoc. and Crypto Council for Innovation v. IL · SIFMA
- 18 Crypto Firms Seek to Join Court Fight Over Illinois’ 0.2% Crypto Tax · Unchained
- Washington, Main Street, Wall Street, and DeFi Unite Against Illinois’ Digital Asset Tax · Blockchain Association
- Illinois Department of Revenue Invites Public Review and Comment on Draft Proposed Rules for Digital Asset Tax · Illinois Department of Revenue
- Plaintiffs’ November 4 motion for summary judgment · Blockchain Association
- October 30 joint comment letter on draft rules implementing the Digital Asset Tax Act · Crypto Council for Innovation and Blockchain Association
Sources used during research. Check their dates and original context before relying on a figure. How we report.